March 4, 2015    

Chris McDonnell, UK 

Iconoclasts

(Comments welcome here)

chris@mcdonnell83.freeserve.co.uk

Previous articles by Chris



   

                     The turbulence in Iraq and Syria and the emergence of the Islamic Republic has produced so many accounts of pain, confusion and killing, carried through in acts of vengeance and sheer brutality. The fear and anguish of those who have suffered can only be unavoidably imagined.

 Now in the last few days we have seen the wanton destruction of ancient statues and early written texts in the museum of the city of Mosul . With sledge hammers power tools and pick axes, the images were toppled and reduced to rubble on the floor, the manuscripts burned.

 Irreplaceable.

 Many Iraqis evoke a popular saying about the loss of non-human objects: 'May the books be a sacrifice for the people.'

 This is but the latest incident in the human history of iconoclastic events over the years. During the Byzantine era, the systematic destruction of early Christian images took place; very few examples survived. In the Monastery of St Catherine in the Sinai Desert there are some examples of icons, possibly from the 5th/6th Centuries, but nothing compared to the number that were destroyed.

 Much nearer our own time, when the Reformation was gathering pace in Europe , images in churches and wall paintings of biblical scenes were not tolerated. The statues were destroyed and the walls painted over. A plain, sparse church building was the result. Given the number of parish churches there must have been in England alone, a great deal has been lost. Now and then in a church from this period, fragments are found when the whitewash is removed. Of the statues, there is no trace.

 In more recent times, in 2001, we witnessed the demolition of the Buddhas at Bamiyan in Afghanistan by the Taliban. The two huge images had been carved from the rock in the mid-500s and had stood in the silence of the desert for nearly 1500 years, near to the Silk Road that runs through the Hindu Kush mountains. Now they are gone. An empty space remains where once they stood.

 

              A few days after those events in March, 2001, I wrote these lines

The breaking of statues

 

Still shapes of some significance

whose form, full fashioned

from cliff-face rock

may have a deeper meaning

and understanding

beyond artistic expression.

 

For there, after the silence

of stilled hands, brittle-boned

and now returned to the earth,

they left statues gazing

to the sky, the sun and the stars,

speechless yet speaking

of each restless spirit moving

through stages of completion.

 

There they remained until came

the time for the breaking of statues,

the deliberate reduction

of sand-blown curves

and towering ancient presence

to fine fragments

of no particular meaning,

the re-arrangement of sacred stone

in the dust of the desert floor.

   

The murderous treatment that we have seen in recent weeks in an attempt to subjugate people and enforce control through fear has filled our screens and newspapers, evil acts that belie the Moslem faith.  To destroy the historical and sacred links with their past only adds to their indignity.

 This loss, from the cradle of civilisation, is a loss to the heritage of all humanity.

 END

----------