November 18, 2015    

Chris McDonnell, UK 

Change ain’t easy

(Comments welcome here)

chris@mcdonnell83.freeserve.co.uk

Previous articles by Chris

 

Last week, a storm swept in from the Atlantic bringing high winds and rain to the northern part of the UK . We are, after all, approaching Winter in the northern hemisphere, so we shouldn’t be surprised.

 Yet this one was different.

 For the first time in the UK we had a storm that had a name, Abigail. Over many years we have got use to hurricanes in the Western hemisphere, as well at typhoons in the Pacific basin, having names. The National Hurricane Centre (NHC) in the US lists each year the names for expected storms, alternatively choosing male and female names. Now the Met Offices in London and Dublin have adopted the same pattern of identifying storms; hence the arrival of Abigail. Gertrude gets her place later in the list.

“We are not living an era of change but a change of era.”

Changing the way we describe a weather system is a small matter, change within the Church is quite another ball game. These words of Francis are well worth considering.

 In the years since the close of the second council of the Vatican we have passed through three quite clearly distinct periods. First, we experienced the amazing shock of those three years of the Council, called by John XXIII, followed by the papacy of Paul VI. The spirit of change was in the air, expectancy and hope abounded. The consequent fall out from the encyclical of 1968 is of course, still with us. During the 70s we also lost numerous priests and religious for a multitude of reasons. You might say that we treated them with a lack of care and charity. There lies the root of a crisis we now face, with an advancing age profile of those who stayed and very few entering seminary to replace them in the coming years.

 By the time John Paul and Benedict occupied the See of Rome, the energy of the Council was in decline. During those decades, there was a concerted attempt to apply the brakes, to look back and seek the holy comfort zone of history as a place for refuge.

 That was never going to work and our problems as a people, Christians bearing the Lord’s name, continued to grow. The arrival in Rome of Jorge Bergolio from Argentina , the first pope to take the name of Francis, was a sea change (if you will pardon the pun) of the first order.

 “Before the problems of the church it is not useful to search for solutions in conservatism or fundamentalism, in the restoration of obsolete conduct and forms that no longer have the capacity of being significant culturally,” he  said at one point during his remarks.

“Christian doctrine is not a closed system incapable of generating questions, doubts, interrogatives — but is alive, knows being unsettled, enlivened,” said the pope. “It has a face that is not rigid, it has a body that moves and grows, it has a soft flesh: it is called Jesus Christ.”

Those remarks made recently by Francis in Florence ,  neatly sum up his mission, to walk forward with us, a pilgrim in a pilgrim Church .

 There are many issues that we face but not all have immediate solutions. We have to be persistent yet patient. In the exercise of patience, we must take care not to create groups who won’t listen to each other. For unless we talk and listen there will be no development.

 So in the end there has to be openness. We can name storms for easy reference in the weather forecast but let’s be very careful when it comes to labels within the Church. Divergence of opinion has been a fact of the humanity of the Church through the ages and has so often led to closure in our discussions and consequently lost opportunities. Rather like storms, we have this tendency to name groups before we feel able to discuss their position.

 In our cautiousness don’t let us forget the critical times which it is our lot to occupy. For it is now that we need informed conversations. How we handle the post-synod exchange will be a measure of our spirit.

 

 

END

-----